Crime Traveller
  
Subscribe
  • Home
  • Research
    Young people who join gangs

    Why Do Young People Join Gangs? Members Explain the Appeal of Risk Taking

    Study Psychology Online: Resources To Get Started

    High school sexual assault

    3 Themes From National News Coverage of 3 Sexual Assaults

    Trending Tags

    • Neuroscience
    • Mental Health
    • Criminal Brain
    • Juvenile Crime
  • Psychology

    The Question of Why: Did Ted Bundy have Dissociative Identity Disorder?

    Teenage psychopathy

    What Should We Do With Teenage Psychopaths?

    A Criminal Disorder? Advances in Neurocriminology Are Leading The Way

    Trending Tags

    • Narcissism
    • Psychopathy
    • Profiling
    • Mental Health
    • Psychology
  • Family Violence
    Melanie McGuire

    A Convicted Killer, Two Criminologists, and One Podcast: Direct Appeal Investigates ‘Suitcase Killer’ Melanie McGuire Case

    Family Annihilation: The Crimes and Psychology of Familicide

    A Parent’s Murder and a 16-Year-old Daughter’s Conviction: The Sarah Johnson Parricide Case

    An Innocent Man [Part III]: The Trial of Dr Jeffrey MacDonald – A Critique of the Case

    An Innocent Man [Part II]: The Trial of Dr Jeffrey MacDonald – A Critique of the Case

  • True Crime
    Image: Shutterstock

    A Question of Legitimate Defence: The Castle Doctrine and Justice in Argentina

    How He Did It: A Reporter Investigates An Alabama Sheriff Who Pocketed Over $2 Million in Jail Food Funds

    Image Source: CNN - US-funded police linked to illegal executions in El Salvador

    Police At Center of Government-Sponsored Death Squads in El Salvador

    Trending Tags

    • Unsolved
    • Serial Murder
    • Documentaries
    • Guest Posts
  • Crime Spotlight
    rats

    A Case of Missing Evidence: Rabid Rodents or Corrupt Cops?

    psychic ball and hands

    The Psychology of Psychics Who Claim to be Crime Solvers

    Joker

    Joker Makes For Uncomfortable Viewing – It Shows How Society Creates Extremists

    The Latest Terrorist Threat: Online Conspiracy Theorists

    Addicted To Killing: Serial Killers and The Addiction Cycle

  • Book Reviews

    Psychiatric Killings In The UK: Blood, Voices and Missed Appointments

    New True Crime Book Series from Skyhorse Publishing

    She’s So Cold: Murder, Accusations and the System That Devastated a Family

    Trending Tags

    • Interviews
    • Historical Crime Books
No Result
View All Result
Crime Traveller
  • Home
  • Research
    Young people who join gangs

    Why Do Young People Join Gangs? Members Explain the Appeal of Risk Taking

    Study Psychology Online: Resources To Get Started

    High school sexual assault

    3 Themes From National News Coverage of 3 Sexual Assaults

    Trending Tags

    • Neuroscience
    • Mental Health
    • Criminal Brain
    • Juvenile Crime
  • Psychology

    The Question of Why: Did Ted Bundy have Dissociative Identity Disorder?

    Teenage psychopathy

    What Should We Do With Teenage Psychopaths?

    A Criminal Disorder? Advances in Neurocriminology Are Leading The Way

    Trending Tags

    • Narcissism
    • Psychopathy
    • Profiling
    • Mental Health
    • Psychology
  • Family Violence
    Melanie McGuire

    A Convicted Killer, Two Criminologists, and One Podcast: Direct Appeal Investigates ‘Suitcase Killer’ Melanie McGuire Case

    Family Annihilation: The Crimes and Psychology of Familicide

    A Parent’s Murder and a 16-Year-old Daughter’s Conviction: The Sarah Johnson Parricide Case

    An Innocent Man [Part III]: The Trial of Dr Jeffrey MacDonald – A Critique of the Case

    An Innocent Man [Part II]: The Trial of Dr Jeffrey MacDonald – A Critique of the Case

  • True Crime
    Image: Shutterstock

    A Question of Legitimate Defence: The Castle Doctrine and Justice in Argentina

    How He Did It: A Reporter Investigates An Alabama Sheriff Who Pocketed Over $2 Million in Jail Food Funds

    Image Source: CNN - US-funded police linked to illegal executions in El Salvador

    Police At Center of Government-Sponsored Death Squads in El Salvador

    Trending Tags

    • Unsolved
    • Serial Murder
    • Documentaries
    • Guest Posts
  • Crime Spotlight
    rats

    A Case of Missing Evidence: Rabid Rodents or Corrupt Cops?

    psychic ball and hands

    The Psychology of Psychics Who Claim to be Crime Solvers

    Joker

    Joker Makes For Uncomfortable Viewing – It Shows How Society Creates Extremists

    The Latest Terrorist Threat: Online Conspiracy Theorists

    Addicted To Killing: Serial Killers and The Addiction Cycle

  • Book Reviews

    Psychiatric Killings In The UK: Blood, Voices and Missed Appointments

    New True Crime Book Series from Skyhorse Publishing

    She’s So Cold: Murder, Accusations and the System That Devastated a Family

    Trending Tags

    • Interviews
    • Historical Crime Books
Crime Traveller
Home Psychology of Murder

How The Insanity Defence Against A Murder Charge Works

by Guest Author
11 December, 2015
in Psychology of Murder
4 min read
5
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

The Conversation – Arlie Loughnan, University of Sydney

AMelbourne man was found not guilty this week of murdering a homeless man by reason of mental impairment. The man, Easton Woodhead, who suffers from schizophrenia, killed Morgan Perry, believing Perry had stolen his motorcycle. A Supreme Court jury acquitted Woodhead of murder on the basis of mental impairment.

This type of case frequently raises concerns about the validity of this defence. There is a preconception that the mental illness and related defences are seen in the public discourse as “get out of jail free” cards; illegitimate excuses – perhaps even fabricated or made up – allowing some individuals to “get off” criminal charges.

According to this logic, successful mental illness defences are suspect. But, contrary to this logic, we should be concerned about the low numbers of people charged with criminal offences who raise what is known in criminal law as the mental impairment or mental illness defence.

It’s hard to be precise about numbers here, but we do know that very few individuals successfully raise defences such as insanity or mental illness. The NSW Law Reform Commission found just 32 successful defences in 2011-12.

Why is the defence so rarely used?

What’s going on here? How does this square with what we know about the high numbers of individuals in prison with mental illnesses?

Part of the explanation is the difference between medical and legal definitions of “insanity”. Only a selection of mental illnesses, as understood by psychiatrists and psychologists, qualify as mental illness for the criminal law.

For the insanity defence, mental illness must affect the individual in a particular way. It must affect his or her reasoning processes – his or her cognitive capacity – not “just” affect emotion or volition. This immediately rules out many genuine mental conditions that can seriously impact someone’s life.

The difference between legal and medical definitions is part of the reason for the gap between numbers of prisoners with mental illness and the use of the mental illness defence. Another reason for this gap, and the injustice that results from it, is to do with the criminal law.

Here’s the rub: in an attempt to respect people as autonomous individuals, the criminal law assumes everyone is sane.

Assuming everyone charged with a criminal offence is sane, and responsible for their actions, entails assuming that individuals have particular capacities (of cognition, volition and morality). If an accused lacks the necessary capacities, he or she is not responsible and cannot be held to account for his or her actions in the context of a criminal trial and conviction.

Raising the insanity or mental illness defence involves making a claim of non-responsibility.

What is the legal test for ‘insanity’?

NSW criminal law relies on the M’Naghten Rules to define the test for insanity. The M’Naghten Rules require that: (1) an individual suffers from a “defect of reason”, which is (2) caused by a “disease of the mind”, and, as a result, (3) he or she does not know the “nature and quality” of the act or that it was wrong.

This language sounds arcane, and it is. The M’Naghten decision dates from 1843. The effect of the decision is that it is really difficult to raise the mental illness defence successfully.

Like other states in Australia, Victoria, where Woodhead was tried, has a statutory insanity provision based on the M’Naghten Rules.

The limitations of this test are clear:

  1. not all severe mental illness affects reasoning capacity;
  2. no psychiatrists use the term “disease of the mind”; and
  3. requiring people to be so profoundly affected that they don’t know the nature and quality of their act or that it is wrong sets the bar too high.

The vast majority of people with serious mental illness would fail this test. We need to bring the law up to date with current medical knowledge. We need a genuinely accessible insanity defence. This would help direct people who really need it into treatment.

Defence does not let people ‘walk free’

In Australia and elsewhere, an accused found to be insane is exposed to special court powers of disposal. If an individual is not criminally responsible, he or she isn’t free to walk away as if acquitted. Detention in a secure psychiatric unit in a prison can be just as long – or longer – than any prison term. Treatment rather than punishment is not a “get out of jail” card.

If a genuinely accessible insanity defence provides treatment for people who really need it, it’s better for both the individual and society.

And, before we assume any option other than “proper” punishment is just too lenient, we must pause to think about what having an insanity defence that is genuinely accessible really means.

Exempting insane defendants from criminal responsibility is the flipside of holding people to account only when they are properly agents of their own actions. This means it is the “price” we pay for a system that treats us all as responsible unless proven otherwise.


Arlie Loughnan, Associate Professor in Law, University of Sydney. This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

ADVERTISEMENT
Tags: Mental Health
Share35Tweet21Pin8

Related Posts

Joker
Crime Spotlight

Joker Makes For Uncomfortable Viewing – It Shows How Society Creates Extremists

10 October, 2019
The intriguing case of French serial killer Henri Désiré Landru
True Crime & Justice

France’s Lonely Hearts Serial Killer and the Strange Case of the Missing Notebook

4 December, 2018
Involuntary intoxication by prescribed medications
Crime Research

Prescription For Violence: The Involuntary Intoxication Through Prescribed Medication Defense

11 December, 2018
Crime Research

Antidepressants and the Risks of Committing Homicide

16 July, 2018
Crime Research

Effects Of Seeing An Offender As A Victim In The Genetic Mental Disorder Defense

7 July, 2018
Book Reviews

Mad or Bad? When Crime Met Madness and The Insanity Plea

6 July, 2018

Comments 5

  1. Travacor says:
    4 years ago

    Woah! I’m really loving the template/theme
    of this blog. It’s simple, yet effective. A lot of times it’s tough
    to get that “perfect balance” between user friendliness and visual appeal.
    I must say that you’ve done a great job with this.
    Additionally, the blog loads very fast for me on Safari.
    Superb Blog!

  2. Sanajeh69 says:
    4 years ago

    Lov ur blog iam glad i found it.lov all the storie always interesting.somethin new evry time

  3. Fiona Guy says:
    4 years ago

    Thank you, how kind and I am glad you are enjoying the blog! I hope you will continue to enjoy future posts too.

  4. Michal Lermond says:
    3 years ago

    Thank’s great post.

  5. JesseRPoggio says:
    3 years ago

    Wow! Eventually I got to an internet site from which I’ve learned how to actually obtain valuable information regarding my study and knowledge.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We use cookies to offer you a better browsing experience, show you relevant advertising and analyze site traffic. Read how we use cookies and how you can control them in our Cookie Policy Learn More
ADVERTISEMENT

What's New?

Book Reviews

Psychiatric Killings In The UK: Blood, Voices and Missed Appointments

30 November, 2019
Young people who join gangs
Crime Research

Why Do Young People Join Gangs? Members Explain the Appeal of Risk Taking

12 November, 2019
rats
Crime Spotlight

A Case of Missing Evidence: Rabid Rodents or Corrupt Cops?

8 November, 2019

Stay Connected

Affiliate Disclosure

Crime Traveller is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.

Search

No Result
View All Result

Categories

You Might Also Like

Book Reviews

One Family’s Dark Secret: Joseph Tarricone, A Death On Canyon Road

6 July, 2018
Book Reviews

Cold Case Jury: Charles Bravo Poisoning At The Priory

24 December, 2016
Crime Spotlight

David Koresh: The Rise and Fall Of The Branch Davidians

7 February, 2016
Psychology of Murder

An Interview With Former FBI Profiler Mark Safarik on Violent Offending and Criminal Behavioral Analysis

31 August, 2017

Popular

The Jennifer Pan Story: A Daughter’s Deadly Deception

1 December, 2016
Melanie McGuire

A Convicted Killer, Two Criminologists, and One Podcast: Direct Appeal Investigates ‘Suitcase Killer’ Melanie McGuire Case

17 May, 2019

Recent

Psychiatric Killings In The UK: Blood, Voices and Missed Appointments

30 November, 2019
Young people who join gangs

Why Do Young People Join Gangs? Members Explain the Appeal of Risk Taking

12 November, 2019

Site Links

  • About Crime Traveller
  • Contact Page
  • Become A Guest Contributor
  • Get Your True Crime Book Reviewed
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Cookies
  • DMCA
  • Newsletter

Copyright © 2016 - 2019 Crime Traveller, a website owned and operated by Alythium | All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Crime Research
  • Psychology of Murder
  • Family Violence & Homicide
  • True Crime & Justice
  • Crime Spotlight
  • Book Reviews
  • Get Your True Crime Book Reviewed
  • Become A Guest Contributor
  • Newsletter

Copyright © 2016 - 2019 Crime Traveller, a website owned and operated by Alythium | All Rights Reserved.